12/23/2025 - Introducing "Unseen Footsteps," JUMPS Team Investigation Episodes!

The JUMPS Team
The JUMPS Team
  • Home
  • About
  • Request An Investigation
  • Lectures
  • Investigation Archives
    • Evidence Archives
    • Barrett's Plantation #1
    • Barrett's Plantation #2
    • Battleship New Jersey
    • Churchlanding Farm
    • Clarksboro Residence
    • Clayton Residence
    • Elsinboro Farmhouse
    • Franklinville Residence
    • Gettysburg, PA
    • Gill Memorial Library
    • Johnson Hall #1
    • Johnson Hall #2
    • Johnson Hall #3
    • Marlton Private Residence
    • Mill Hollow Cemetery
    • Monster Pets
    • Old Salem Courthouse
    • Overlook Cemetery
    • Salem Municipal Building
    • Willow & Main Market
    • Woodstown Hotel
  • Private Ghost Tours
  • More
    • Home
    • About
    • Request An Investigation
    • Lectures
    • Investigation Archives
      • Evidence Archives
      • Barrett's Plantation #1
      • Barrett's Plantation #2
      • Battleship New Jersey
      • Churchlanding Farm
      • Clarksboro Residence
      • Clayton Residence
      • Elsinboro Farmhouse
      • Franklinville Residence
      • Gettysburg, PA
      • Gill Memorial Library
      • Johnson Hall #1
      • Johnson Hall #2
      • Johnson Hall #3
      • Marlton Private Residence
      • Mill Hollow Cemetery
      • Monster Pets
      • Old Salem Courthouse
      • Overlook Cemetery
      • Salem Municipal Building
      • Willow & Main Market
      • Woodstown Hotel
    • Private Ghost Tours
  • Home
  • About
  • Request An Investigation
  • Lectures
  • Investigation Archives
    • Evidence Archives
    • Barrett's Plantation #1
    • Barrett's Plantation #2
    • Battleship New Jersey
    • Churchlanding Farm
    • Clarksboro Residence
    • Clayton Residence
    • Elsinboro Farmhouse
    • Franklinville Residence
    • Gettysburg, PA
    • Gill Memorial Library
    • Johnson Hall #1
    • Johnson Hall #2
    • Johnson Hall #3
    • Marlton Private Residence
    • Mill Hollow Cemetery
    • Monster Pets
    • Old Salem Courthouse
    • Overlook Cemetery
    • Salem Municipal Building
    • Willow & Main Market
    • Woodstown Hotel
  • Private Ghost Tours

Homestead Orphanage

Case Details

DATE: April 17, 2014

LOCATION: 777 Baltimore Street, Gettysburg, PA

Group 1 Investigators

  • Doug Hogate Jr - Lead Investigator
  • Kelly Roncace - Investigator
  • Catrena Clair - Investigator
  • Mellie DeVault - Investigator
  • Linda Lopez - Guest Investigator
  • Collette DeVault - Special Guest Investigator
  • Jeremy Dark - Special Guest Investigator

Group 2 Investigators

  • BJ Hoffman - Lead Investigator
  • Tiffany Hoffman - Investigator
  • Rob Johnson - Investigator
  • Jen Stubbins - Investigator
  • Al Pagano - Investigator
  • Tim McGuire- Investigator
  • Lisa McGuire - Guest Investigator
  • Kodi & Morgan Hoffman - Child Investigators

Group 1 - Investigation Report

Joined by JUMPS Team members Kelly Roncace, Catrena Clair, and Mellie DeVault, we entered the Orphanage and immediately began a tour with the guide. Joining us was Guest Investigator Linda Lopez who is also my Mother, and Child Guest Investigators Jeremy Dark (14) and Collette DeVault (15). The tour guide immediately escorted us to the basement where the heart of the activity awaited. Once she described the activity she returned to the upper floor. We wasted no time placing the equipment and turned out all the lights to begin our investigation.


When we began the investigation, we sent child guest investigators Collette DeVault and Jeremy Dark into the dungeon. The purpose of having them on the investigation was to see if their presence would increase the activity from child spirits or the spirit of Rosa Carmichael herself. Jeremy and Collette placed a REM Pod on the floor in the center of the dungeon, each had K2 Meters in hand, and an audio recorder. The rest of the group remained outside of the dungeon, positioned on the benches placed for the tours, and observed the two teenagers. Collette began with simple questions for an EVP session. During the early stages of the investigation, all seemed quiet and calm. Then suddenly, as we all listened and observed the two teenagers in the dungeon, we heard a gasp from both of them. When asked what was wrong, Collette responded that both of the K2 Meters they were holding began to light for a few seconds then stop. I encouraged them to take the opportunity to begin instructing the spirits to do the same thing to the devices as a means of communications. Meanwhile, we began our own EVP session in the main area of the basement. Again, all was calm. I then took the opportunity to have a seat in the doorway to the dungeon while placing the Mel Meter near me to measure any changes in electromagnetic fields and temperature. I also activated the REM Pod feature on the Mel Meter and placed it in a position so that if any spirit were to approach me I would be warned immediately. Once that was in place, I began encouraging the child spirits to come forward to communicate. With that, I explained that they were allowed to speak and move around and that I would not let the “mean lady upstairs” (Rosa Carmichael) hurt them or punish them. I also invited the child spirits to come close and place their arms around me, which was a claim that I read about prior to the investigation that would occur to visitors in the basement of the Orphanage. With the invites and communication attempts, no activity occurred for some time.


Finally, I decided to stand up from the step I was sitting on in the entrance of the dungeon. As I went to stand, I placed both of my hands on each wall to pull myself up. While pushing myself up, I accidentally pushed the old wooden door to the dungeon against the wall which caused a loud bang. Instantly, all the K2 meters, the Mel Meter, and the REM Pod simultaneously came on. I immediately apologized to all the spirits as I did not intend to frighten them. The alarms continued to sound for approximately 5 seconds before stopping. Did my unintended door slam trigger some sort of residual energy in the basement of child spirits scattering to hide because they felt Rosa was coming? After this incident, the team members decided to sweep the basement to see if they could find where the child spirits may be hiding while Jeremy and Collette remained in the dungeon.


Linda Lopez, guest investigator and also my Mother, stood up from one of the benches in the area and moved over to a table full of children’s toys that was placed toward the back side of the basement. In a relaxed caring voice, she began asking any child spirit if they would like to get close to her to play with the toys. After continuing to invite, finally she began to notice her K2 meter begin to light. With that reaction, she then took a blue toy truck from the table and placed it on the floor in front of her. She then requested that if a child was near her that he/she make the device in her hand react then push and play with the toy on the floor so that she and the other investigators would know they were present. Suddenly, causing considerable surprise, the toy on the floor moved from its position as if someone pushed it using force. At the exact same time this occurred, the K2 Meter in Linda’s hand began to flash as well. The team members began to direct questions to a child spirit that they believed was present and playing with the toy. They asked questions such as the child’s name, age, how long they were in the basement, and so on. Following each question the K2 meters responded continuously for some time. After several minutes, the K2 responses began to decrease and no additional incidents occurred with the toy that moved on its own.     


Meanwhile, in the dungeon, Collette and Jeremy were getting some minor activity themselves. Still holding a K2 Meter each, they also began noticing some consistency in responses with questions. However, their K2 meters would respond when questions were directed toward children and toward Rosa Carmichael. During their EVP session, Collette began provoking Rosa and the older children who were said to have helped Rosa in harming the children during the days of the Orphanage. She told Rosa that she had no power over her and asked her how she felt about that statement, as well as the other statements she made coming from a child. Again, each question had some sort of response on the K2 Meter but Collette and Jeremy were unable to determine if those responses were from a child spirit or the spirit of Rosa Carmichael herself.


After several minutes of investigating in the dungeon with our “trigger objects” Collette and Jeremy and in the main section of the basement with the table of toys, I felt it was time to switch areas. Therefore, I moved Collette and Jeremy into the main area while Kelly, Mellie, Linda, and I moved into the dungeon. Catrena remained in the main section of the basement with Jeremy and Collette.


The dungeon is a dark and low room. The darkness was so intense that you could not see your own hand in front of you without a light. To truly take ourselves back in time, we decided to shut the door to separate ourselves from the three others in the main section and to see what the children who were thrown in there felt. We were equipped with two K2 meters, the Mel Meter, the REM Pod, an audio recorder, and the Ovilous; a device that generates an internal white noise energy and if that energy is broken by some sort of audible sound, the built in dictionary will say the word it believes was heard in a robotic voice.


I placed myself down low near the REM Pod. I wanted to take the opportunity to truly connect with the children who were thrown in the dungeon and mistreated after losing their fathers in the battle. I began by introducing myself and explained that I had 3 children of my own and that I could be trusted. Kelly, Mellie, and Linda also explained that they were Mothers. I continued to also explain that they did not have to be afraid of anyone and that I was there and would be sure that nothing bad would happen if they would come out to talk. Seconds after I began to explain this, the REM Pod sounded right in front of me. What made this incident different from witnessing the REM Pod sound other times is that I began to feel a change in my surroundings as if some sort of heavy energy approached me and remained. I continued asking questions to learn more about the child. Again, a few questions were asked with no responses including, “was your father in the Union Army or Confederate Army?” Approximately 30 seconds later, the Ovilous finally said a word which was, “GRAY.” What validated this even more was that at the same time the word was said on the Ovilous, the K2 meter next to it flashed quickly. Unsure if this was a direct response saying that their father belonged to the Confederate Army (Confederates typically wore gray uniforms) or the Ovilous picked up some other word. Either way, we continued to take in and absorb the information we were gathering and continued with our session. Kelly, Mellie, and Linda began asking questions to see what responses they would receive while I remained in position near the REM Pod. A few questions passed with no responses. Finally, I interrupted and asked if the child was still present. Immediately, the REM Pod and K2 meters all responded. At this point, it seemed as if the responses would only occur if I asked them. To confirm this, Mellie asked the spirit if they only responded to me because I remind them of their father. With no hesitation, the REM Pod and other devices all sounded again. At this point, I stood up and repositioned myself closer to the wall where the bottom of the pit was located. We continued reaching out to that same spirit that seemed to be communicating with us through the devices. After I relocated my position, there was only one more additional reaction from the REM Pod before it stopped. We began discussing what had been occurring for the last 30 minutes and trying to come up with a conclusion as to who we may have been communicating with and what they were telling us. During this discussion, Linda quickly reached behind her hood on her sweatshirt. I noticed this and asked her what was wrong. She asked if she was up against a pipe or some other object in the area where she was standing. I immediately looked behind her and saw that she was approximately 2 feet away from anything and nothing was or could have brushed against her. I then checked for hanging objects or spider webs and found nothing. She then described what she felt; as if her hood was being pulled down slightly. We continued our conversation and not 60 seconds later, she interrupted by explaining that the same thing had happened again. I again checked as I did before but there were no changes and nothing was observed. 


In the main section of the basement, Collette, Jeremy, and Catrena were getting their own responses on their K2 meters as well has having minor personal experiences. At this time, they were concentrating on communicating with children and using the toys on the table as trigger objects. Occasionally, during their line of questioning, they were getting some K2 responses as well as hearing some faint whispers. At one point, a whisper was so noticeable, Collette asked Jeremy if he said something. Jeremy did not but said he had heard the same thing. Also during their session, Jeremy was positioned on a bench while observing his K2 meter. He then began to notice something unusual with his shorts. He felt as if someone began slightly pulling on them. While inexperienced in investigating, he did the natural thing and repositioned his leg. Then, seconds later, he felt another tug although this time even harder. Again, he brushed away this feeling and nothing else occurred.


At this time, I decided to leave the dungeon leaving the women inside to see if they would get any responses from children. I joined Catrena, Collette, and Jeremy to see how they were making out with their investigation. Catrena began to explain that she would occasionally feel very sad and overwhelmed and the energy was becoming very strong to her. I immediately checked to be sure she was alright and asked if she needed to leave the area. Suddenly, she began to cry as if strong emotions had overcome her because of the things that had occurred in the basement where we were standing. I immediately had Collette escort her to the second floor so she could get out of the situation. At that point, everyone regrouped in the main section of the basement to let things calm down. Once Catrena was away, I began provoking any negative spirit whether Rosa or someone else who may have made Catrena begin feeling that way. I demanded that if they could make her feel that way to come forward and do the same to me. Unfortunately, after much effort, nothing occurred.


After a thorough and exciting sweep of each area in the basement of the Homestead Orphanage, it became time to switch locations. Therefore, I instructed the team to gather the equipment and I checked on Catrena who was with the volunteer on the upper levels. Catrena assured me that she was fine and that she had cried because a sudden feeling of sadness had overcome her. The Orphanage volunteer stated that what Catrena felt is something many visitors, paranormal teams, and even volunteers have felt on numerous occasions.


he rest of them team met with us in the main store and we exited to make our way to our next location; The Jennie Wade House.

Group 2 - Investigation Report

Coming from their investigation of the Jennie Wade House down the street, the next group arrived at the Homestead Orphanage to see if they might have the same luck as our group did earlier in the basement where children were reportedly left for days as punishment.


The group of BJ Hoffman, Tiffany Hoffman, Rob Johnson, Jen Stubbins, Al Pagano, Tim McGuire, and guest investigators Lisa McGuire and Kodi & Morgan Hoffman descended the wooden steps into the dark basement to begin their investigation of the famous Orphanage. They began with a brief tour with one of the volunteers and then were locked inside with the spirits that still like to make themselves known.


To begin the investigation, Tiffany entered the dungeon area and sat next to the hole in the wall which is at the base of the pit. The rest of the team equipped themselves with K2 meters, a Mel Meter, and digital audio recorder and took a seat in the main section of the basement near the back wall where children were allegedly chained to the wall. Also in that area was the table of toys left for the children spirits to play with.


As soon as everyone was settled, the lights went out and the investigation began. BJ wasted no time and began conducting the type of EVP session he enjoys the most; provoking. He began demanding that Rosa Carmichael make herself known and to address him as she did the innocent children over 150 years ago. As soon as he began his defensive attack, all the K2 meters in the area began to light. Just for clarification, Tim spoke up and requested that if Rosa was present and caused the K2 meter he was holding to respond to do so a second time. In an instant, it did. With this potentially direct response, BJ continued his provoking by inviting Rosa to approach him and touch and or attack him as she did the children. After several minutes, no other responses occurred. Al began another approach and began addressing any child spirits that may be present. Unlike before, BJ calmed his voice and behavior so that he would not frighten any children present and explained that he only acted that way because she was a very terrible lady. The team began demonstrating all the equipment they had in front of them and explained to the children how they worked. They spent several minutes asking different types of questions but did not receive any responses. As an experiment, BJ wanted to see if anything would happen if he spoke to Rosa again. Therefore, he asked if Rosa was still nearby and like before the K2 meters responded.


While BJ was trying to determine if it truly was Rosa responding in the main area of the basement, Tiffany and JJ addressed the children in the dungeon area. As soon as they began, their K2 meters began to respond as well. With the back and forth responses to kids and Rosa Carmichael, they advised the children to not be afraid of her regardless of whether she was present or not. As soon as that comment was made, the K2 meters as well as the Mel Meter began to react strongly.


For the next experiment, BJ wanted to attempt something that was successful in 2012 when the JUMPS Team investigated the Salem County Insane Asylum. BJ began to explain to the children present that they could use the K2 meter to tell the team how old they were. He explained that when he said their age to cause the K2 meter lights to flash. Then, he began saying ages beginning with 5. He reached up to 10 years old and received no responses. Just to be sure, he then began at 5 and went down to 1 but again no responses.


Next, Tim wanted to attempt an experiment to address a spirit that has been said to be the one who shows himself the most in the basement. It has been said that Tommy’s favorite toy on the table is the blue car. Therefore, Tim took the blue car and placed it in front of him with the K2next to it to measure if the energy changed if the car were to move on its own. He began inviting Tommy to come play with his car to show that he was there with them. After a few minutes, there were no reactions or responses. Tim then asked if the reason he was not coming forward was because Rosa was there and he is afraid. Again, no responses. At this point with little activity, Kodi (BJ and Tiffany Hoffman’s son), began to feel uncomfortable and did not want to be there anymore. Therefore, BJ left the area with him and Morgan Hoffman, his daughter, while the rest of the team remained.


The team continued reaching out to the different spirits that have been reported to be in the basement. Jen even reached out to the child spirit that was believed to have a connection with me when my group was there during the first part of the investigation. Unfortunately, there were no responses.


Time went on and they continued to ask questions directed to the children, Rosa, even possible soldiers because the building was a hospital during the time of the Battle of Gettysburg. Again, there were no responses.


The remainder of the investigation, the team attempted to develop personal connections with the spirits; such as Tim announcing that he was a police officer and would protect the children from Rosa, announcing that every person in the basement was a parent therefore they could be trusted, and that Lisa was a nurse and that she could help anyone who may be injured. The only reaction was a brief flash on the K2 when Tim announced he was a police officer. Other than that one incident nothing else occurred.


Suddenly, Al began to notice something in his ear. As someone who wears hearing aids, it has been researched as well as proven that if a spirit speaks loud enough, the voice could possibly be heard live at the same time as being recorded on the audio recorder. Due to the mechanics, it has been proven on past investigations where Al has reported hearing a voice and the audio recorder picked up what he heard. Al stated that he believed he heard a child but was unsure what was being said. The only guess he could make was that he heard “help” however he could not be sure. Jen then stated to the spirits that they were there to help if that was what was being said. Unfortunately, nothing else was heard.


The team members continued on; Tiffany invited a spirit to sit next to her in the dungeon, Jen requested a spirit to pull her hair, which is a claim that has been reported in the past, Al placed a piece of candy on one of the benches for the child spirits, and asked for the spirits to make themselves known in any way. Suddenly, a bigger shock than normal because of the lack of activity, a loud knock was heard coming from the direction of Tim. Rob and Lisa checked all around Tim for anything natural that could have caused the noise but were unable to find anything. Tim took that opportunity to again remind Rosa of how terrible she was hoping to have her react in some way. Unfortunately, there were no responses.


With the night winding down, Tiff and Jen spent the final moments asking if the children hoped to one day be adopted. They even went to the extreme of saying they would adopt them. Then, Jen asked if the spirits even knew they had died. Suddenly, her K2 meter reacted quickly. They made one final attempt to make contact with any spirit, whether the children or Rosa, but nothing else occurred.


Therefore, after a late night and hours spent in the basement where so much emotion and tragedy took place at the hands of Rosa Carmichael, the team decided to bring the investigation to a close.


Respectfully Submitted,

Doug Hogate Jr.

Founder / Lead Investigator of JUMPS

Investigation Findings

Audio



  • As the investigation began, Investigator Kelly Roncace began asking the child spirit what their name was. The digital audio recorder picked up this EVP of a name. What makes this EVP unique is that the name that is being said is the name that has been given to the child spirit who has been reported to be there.


  • EVP 1 - "Timmy"
  • EVP 1a - "Timmy" (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • Approximately 1 minute later, Kelly continued her EVP session by asking the children their ages. What the team did not realize is that an EVP was captured of a possible residual energy left behind from when the building was used as a soldier's hospital during the Battle of Gettysburg.


  • EVP 2 - "Someone save him..."
  • EVP 2a - "Someone save him..." (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • With Guest Child Investigators Collette DeVault and Jeremy Dark in the dungeon and the rest of the group in the main basement area, Doug has a seat at the entrance of the dungeon. After sitting there for several minutes, he decided to stand up by using the walls of the basement to get up. When he pushed again the wall, he accidentally slammed the dungeon door again the wall. Suddenly, all the devices reacting to the incident. This is the recording of that incident.


  • Personal Experience 1 - Door Slams on Doug


  • Guest Investigator Linda Lopez takes the K2 Meter in her hand and makes her way to the table full of toys. She places the toy car that has been said to be Timmy's favorite toy. She placed the toy on the level floor and the team watches invited Timmy to place with it. Suddenly, the toy car takes off with force on it's own. Here is the audio of that incident.


  • Personal Experience 2 - Toy Car Incident


  • After quite a bit of time with Colette and Jeremy alone in the dungeon, Doug decides to switch and have them come to the main area of the basement while he investigates the dungeon. Right before he invites the other investigators to join him, an unexplained whisper was captured.


  • EVP 3 - Unexplained whisper
  • EVP 3a - Unexplained whisper (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • After the switch, Collette and Jeremy position themselves on the benches in the main area of the basement. Joining them was Investigator Catrena. In a distance, Doug is explaining the REM Pod to the other investigators. However, another voice is captured near Collette, Jeremy, and Catrena which is actually heard by Collette.


  • EVP 4 - "Uh huh"
  • EVP 4a - "Uh huh" (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • From the audio recorder closer to Collette, Jeremy, and Catrena, the following is the same as the previous finding however more is being said.


  • EVP 5 - "Uh huh....How are you?"
  • EVP 5a - "Uh huh...How are you?" (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • Again, while Colette, Jeremy, and Catrena were investigating the main area of the basement, their audio recorder picks up another EVP that sounds like someone is singing.


  • EVP 6 - Unexplained singing
  • EVP 6a - Unexplained singing (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • As the investigation continued, Catrena, Collette, and Jeremy began to notice some movement that they could not determine where it was coming from. After one incident, Collette asks the spirit if they were the cause of one in particular sound. The response could not be heard with their own ears.


  • EVP 7 - Laughter
  • EVP 7a - Laughter (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)


  • As time was getting close to switch locations, Investigator Catrena suddenly began to feel an overwhelming sadness. With that she requested to move to the upper floor to help calm down her emotions. As she left the basement, Doug began to provoke Rosa Carmichael for making the emotions in the building so high because of her actions. As he began to provoke, a dark voice was recorded that did not match the way individuals spoke back in the 1800s. Therefore, this EVP recorded was that of a modern day person but unsure who and why they were there.


  • EVP 8 - "What about that, bro?"


  • Moments before leaving the Orphanage, Guest Investigator Linda expressed her thanks to the spirits who communicated by saying they were "great." At the same time, an EVP was captured that was not heard at the time it was recorded.


  • EVP 9 - Unexplained humming
  • EVP 9a - Unexplained humming (BACKGROUND NOISE REMOVED)

Back to Gettysburg, PAInvestigation Archives

Copyright © 2025 Jersey Unique Minds Paranormal Society - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by